Skip to content

vs

Open in Compare portfolios

Feb 6, 2006 – Oct 2, 2026, Rebalanced annually, DBC sets the start date

Final balanceCAGRMax drawdownSharpe ratio
Permanent Portfolio$40,777+7.04%−19.03%0.94
All Weather$37,324+6.59%−23.78%0.83

Growth of $10,000

Loading the growth chart…

Key metrics

ReturnPermanent PortfolioAll Weather
Final balance$40,777$37,324
Total return+307.77%+273.24%
CAGR+7.04%+6.59%
Calendar yearsPermanent PortfolioAll Weather
Best year+22.49%+18.28%
Worst year−13.85%−19.23%
Positive years15 of 1916 of 19
RiskPermanent PortfolioAll Weather
Max drawdown−19.03%−23.78%
Longest drawdown2.5 years3.8 years
Volatility (annualized)7.56%8.09%
Risk-adjustedPermanent PortfolioAll Weather
Sharpe ratio0.940.83
Sortino ratio1.341.18
Calmar ratio0.370.28

Trailing returns

PeriodPermanent PortfolioAll WeatherPermanent Portfolio − All Weather
YTD+0.53%+3.33%−2.80%
1Y+4.51%+4.84%−0.33%
3Y+14.94%+11.33%+3.62%
5Y+6.42%+2.74%+3.68%
10Y+6.70%+5.33%+1.37%
15Y+6.09%+5.84%+0.25%
20Y+7.10%+6.67%+0.43%

Rolling returns

PeriodPermanent Portfolio medianAll Weather medianMore often ahead
1Y+7.92%+8.33%Permanent Portfolio 52%
3Y+6.26%+6.37%All Weather 57%
5Y+6.14%+6.43%All Weather 62%
10Y+6.37%+6.97%All Weather 76%

Worst drawdowns

DeclinePeakBottomRecoveredLength
−19.0%Nov 2021Oct 2022May 20242.5 years
−14.1%Mar 2008Nov 2008Aug 20091.4 years
−11.1%Mar 2020Mar 2020Apr 20202 months
−8.0%Jul 2016Dec 2016Aug 20171.1 years
−7.9%Oct 2012Jun 2013Feb 20141.4 years

Annual returns

YearPermanent PortfolioAll WeatherPermanent Portfolio − All Weather
2017+10.87%+11.75%−0.88%
2018−1.83%−3.08%+1.25%
2019+16.51%+18.28%−1.77%
2020+16.77%+16.36%+0.41%
2021+4.05%+8.16%−4.10%
2022−13.85%−19.23%+5.38%
2023+11.42%+9.96%+1.46%
2024+11.58%+5.99%+5.59%
2025+22.49%+13.42%+9.08%
2026to Oct 2+0.53%+3.33%−2.80%

Holdings

Permanent Portfolio

  • VTIUS total stock market25%
  • TLTLong-term Treasuries25%
  • SHYShort-term Treasuries25%
  • GLDGold25%

All Weather

  • VTIUS total stock market30%
  • TLTLong-term Treasuries40%
  • IEFIntermediate Treasuries15%
  • DBCCommodities7.5%
  • GLDGold7.5%

About Permanent Portfolio vs All Weather

The Permanent Portfolio puts a quarter each in stocks, long-term Treasuries, short-term Treasuries and gold. All Weather has a little more in stocks, 30%, and much more in bonds, 55%, all of them longer term. It holds 7.5% in gold and 7.5% in commodities, against the Permanent Portfolio's 25% in gold.

The Permanent Portfolio returned 7.0% a year from Feb 2006 to Oct 2026, against 6.6% for All Weather. Both fell furthest in 2021–2022, the Permanent Portfolio by 19.0% and All Weather by 23.8%. The Permanent Portfolio beat All Weather in 10 of 19 full years, but All Weather was ahead in 76% of rolling 10-year periods.

Daily closes with dividends reinvested and fund fees included, before taxes and trading costs. Both rebalance once a year. The comparison starts on Feb 6, 2006, when DBC's prices begin.